ZINC / Intelligence

AI Competitor Research: Prompts That Require Proof

October 6, 2026 / / Intelligence

Illustrated competitor product comparison organized by offer, proof and gaps beside public source cards.
TL;DR

Ask for dated public evidence about competitors, not invented sales or strategy. Separate observed offers and claims from interpretation. Verify each source and use the findings to identify a customer need your business can substantiate.

Public pages can show a competitor's offer, pricing and buying process. They usually cannot establish revenue, profit or advertising spend.

Begin with a small set of businesses and a specific buying decision.

Keep the inference visible. 01 / Record what is public: Exact offer, price and stated terms: Source URL and observation date: Label the business’s own claims. 02 / Bound the comparison: Match scope, currency and conditions: Leave missing prices unknown: Do not infer revenue or private spend. 03 / Test your own explanation: Choose one useful hypothesis: Define your baseline and owner: Review your result, not their private data

Step 1: Fix the comparison

Name the market, customer need and businesses. Choose comparable products or services rather than comparing entire companies with different scopes.

Write the observation date. Public prices, stock and messages can change; the matrix needs a point in time.

Step 2: Collect public records

Use a search-enabled research tool, such as the capabilities documented for OpenAI web search or Gemini grounding.

For [businesses] in [market], find public product or service pages relevant to [customer need]. Return the exact URL, observation date, quoted evidence and stated offer. Separate the business's claim from independently observed facts. Leave unavailable information unknown. Do not seek private accounts or documents.

Open each decisive source before adding its finding to the matrix.

Step 3: Build the same fields for every business

Field Acceptable evidence
Offer and scope Exact public page and stated terms
Price Visible amount, currency and conditions
Buying path Observed steps, without submitting a real order
Proof Published case, review or certification; label its origin
Unknowns Information the public evidence does not establish

Convert these verified records into the matrix above. Every factual cell needs its source URL. Use unknown for missing evidence. Do not infer revenue, profit, conversion rate or private ad spend from rankings, reviews, traffic estimates or visible ads.

Step 4: Compare the decision, not the adjectives

Use a reasoning-capable model to identify differences in scope, terms and the buying path. Supply the matrix; do not ask it to reconstruct the evidence from memory.

Identify differences relevant to [buying decision]. Cite the matrix row for each observation. Distinguish observed differences, company claims and hypotheses. Propose one test on our own site for each useful hypothesis.

Step 5: Challenge the comparison

Ask a separate review pass to find mismatched products, expired pages, currencies, missing conditions and repeated sources. Another model's agreement does not validate the claim.

Find comparisons that would change if scope, date or terms were corrected. Do not add facts. List the exact source checks needed before using the conclusion.

Step 6: Choose a test you can measure

Select one change to your own explanation, offer or inquiry path. Record its owner, baseline and review date through business intelligence.

The output is a testable decision supported by public records. Private numbers stay unknown. If the comparison suggests a new marketing channel, check its fit against your own resources with the channel planning guide.

Use a comparison that stays honest

For an illustrative agency comparison, record whether each public service page explains deliverables, responsibilities, evidence and the enquiry process. “No public price found” is an observation. “This agency is expensive” is an unsupported conclusion unless you have comparable current quotes and scope.

If your own page omits delivery responsibilities, test a clearer explanation there. Do not copy a competitor’s claims or invent a differentiator. Save the observed pages and dates so later changes can be distinguished from research errors. Rankings and reviews can suggest where to look; they do not reveal the competitor’s revenue or profitability.

Keep public evidence separate from the hypothesis

Use one row per competitor and comparable offer. Save the exact public URL, date and terms before proposing a change to your own site. A missing price stays unknown; the sheet does not estimate private revenue or ad spend.

Download the public competitor evidence matrix. Open the CSV in your spreadsheet application, keep the specimen labelled, and add your own rows. Pending observations are work to complete, not failed or successful results.

Sources

A question about this article? Message Wendy

ZINC / Request for proposal

Business Intelligence

A clear brief.
A useful next step.

Start with the decisions your reporting needs to support. Tell us about your business, scope and timing.

01 / Your business
02 / What you need
Build
Demand
Intelligence
03 / The context

Jaymie receives your request and coordinates the next step.

Tell us about your project and how to reach you.

ZINC DIGITAL.
ZINC / A conversation
Projects & conversations

Message Jaymie.

Have a question before writing a brief? Jaymie manages incoming inquiries and will help with the next step.

Delivered by email. Jaymie can reply to the address you provide.

ZINC / A conversation
Articles & editorial

Message Wendy.

Ask about an article, a source or an editorial detail. Your message goes directly to Wendy.

Delivered by email. Wendy can reply to the address you provide.